J3355B shuts down when i340-t4 is connected

I got myself a J3355B(new) and RAM(used) for a pfSense install. Tested the RAM and motherboard and everything seems to POST and the RAM showed no errors in Memtest. However when I connect my i340-T4 NIC (used) the machine starts up, shows me the AsRock splash screen and then shuts down. If I remove the card, the board POSTs again.

Does this mean I got a bad card? If so, I might have to start up a Ebay RMA process. Can someone confirm, before i start the RMA process.